While the Red Dead Redemption series offers excellent gameplay and extremely detailed open worlds, it truly excels because of its characters. As such, nailing the cast of a potential Red Dead Redemption movie would be a must, and one fan believes they have found the right lineup.

With such strong storytelling, many have hoped that Red Dead Redemption will become the model for modern day Western movies. While it remains to be seen if this will come to fruition, it is hard to deny the greatness of the character work and dialogue in the Rockstar series. As such, seeing the cast brought to life on the big screen seems like a no-brainer, especially with the increase in movie and TV adaptions for video games. If it ever were to happen, a casting director may want to take Reddit user Alexbrennan2021’s suggestions into consideration.

RELATED: Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Discovers Rare Conversation Between Arthur and Dutch

While it would be incredibly hard to top Roger Clark’s performance as Arthur, Alexbrennan2021 believes that Josh Brolin would do well in the role. Given the actor’s skill at portraying tough characters, as well as experience in Westerns like True Grit and No Country For Old Men, this is a fine choice. Alongside Arthur, the Redditor suggests that Norman Reedus fills the spot of John Marston, a casting that is likely based on the actor’s mannerisms and unique way of speaking.

Rounding out top billing would be Jeff Bridges, another actor that has done his fair share of Westerns. The Redditor would like to see him in the role of gang leader Dutch Van Der Linde, and while he may lack the raspy voice, he certainly has the charisma and intimidation factor needed for the position. Other choices include Clint Eastwood as Hosea, something that proved to be a bit controversial with fans. While he may look the part, many made the argument that he is a bit too rugged for someone like Hosea.

Other options include Pedro Pascal as Javier, a move that would see the Last of Us actor taking on another video game role. John C. Reilly as Uncle received a lot of praise from commenters, while Barry Pepper is an inspired choice for the position of the devious Micah Bell. However, while most of these picks would work, gamers would need to get over some inconsistencies regarding their ages. As pointed out by a few commenters, Brolin and Reedus are far older than Arthur and John would have been in the second game.

With other gang members like Charles, Lenny, and the incredibly popular Sadie Adler not even seen in this fan cast, a movie would clearly be a massive undertaking. Though it would be tough to get big-name actors in every role, this fan cast is full of quality choices.

Red Dead Redemption is available now on PC, PS3 and Xbox 360. Red Dead Redemption 2 is currently available on PC, PS4, Stadia, and Xbox One.

MORE: Red Dead Redemption 2: What is the Whiskey Tree?