When players are hanging out at the Van der Linde camp gang in Red Dead Redemption 2, other gang members may send Arthur out on requests. There is a specific item that they're looking for and they would be grateful if Arthur picked one up on his travels and brought it back to them. For example, Dutch wants a pipe and Sadie wants a Harmonica.

Even little Jack Marston has a request for Arthur: he wants him to go out and find a Penny Dreadful comic. Jack will give players the request at any point after Chapter 2 in the game's story. Players must have completed the fishing story mission first and Jack will only offer up the request in the day.

The Penny Dreadful comics - which focused on bad people doing bad things or supernatural entities - were quite popular at the time. Yet, Red Dead Redemption 2 only includes four of them. Jack isn't fussy and he will accept any one of the four that Arthur finds and brings back for him. The locations of these Penny Dreadful comics are listed below.

Penny Dreadful Location #1 (Wild West Heroes No.132)

Red Dead Redemption 2 Penny Dreadful location 1

The Penny Dreadful titled "Wild West Heroes No. 132" can be found at the Downes Ranch which is directly west of Caliban's Seat and is south-west of Valentine (it's highlighted with the red patch on the map above). The comic can be located in the farmhouse, in the bedroom, in the nightstand which is next to the bed.

Penny Dreadful Location #2 (Otis Miller and the Black-Hearted Lady)

Red Dead Redemption 2 Penny Dreadful location 2

The Penny Dreadful titled "Otis Miller and the Black-Hearted Lady" can be found in the area of New Hanover. Go east from the fence at Emerald Ranch and Emerald Station until you get to a place called Osman's Grove. Osman's Grove is not a pleasant place to be as the house is dilapidated and has a dead body in it. It's the fitting location for a Penny Dreadful then and you'll find it on top of the nightstand.

Penny Dreadful Location #3 (Otis Miller and the Boy from New York)

Red Dead Redemption 2 Penny Dreadful location 3

The Penny Dreadful titled "Otis Miller and the Boy from New York" is located in Lemoyne, in an abandoned village called "Pleasance" which is east of Lagras (on the map it's right above the letter "O" in the world "Lemoyne"). The village of Pleasance features a school and the Penny Dreadful can be found in the classroom. You'll spot it on top of the teacher's desk.

Penny Dreadful Location #4 (Otis Miller and the Arabian Prince)

Red Dead Redemption 2 Penny Dreadful location 4

The fourth and final Penny Dreadful, titled "Otis Miller and the Arabian Prince" is in a cottage at Clawson's Rest. Clawson's Rest is north-west of Valentine and is directly west to where the writing "Dakota River" on the map. Once you're at Clawson's Rest, just look for the draw that's next to the best and pick up the Penny Dreadful.

Once you've located and collected a Penny Dreadful (Jack will be happy with any one of them), just bring it back to camp and talk to Jack. He will be delighted and will even give you a small reward for completing his request.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is available for PS4 and Xbox One.