Without a doubt, Red Dead Redemption is one of Rockstar Games’ most popular games. It may not hold a candle, sales-wise, to Grand Theft Auto, but then again, nothing in the industry really does. It’s more than enough though that many fans hope to see Red Dead Redemption 3, whether it stars Sadie Adler, Jack Marston, or a brand new character someday.

WARNING: Spoilers Ahead for Red Dead Redemption 2Red Dead 3 is not on the foreseeable horizon, but there is plenty of content between the two games to keep returning fans satisfied for quite some time. Of course, one bothersome aspect of replaying Red Dead Redemption 1 is how it never really references Arthur Morgan. It is understandable given that he didn’t really exist until RDR2 was released, but one video has gone viral for showing Jack Marston “imitating” Arthur Morgan.

RELATED: Red Dead Redemption 2 Fan Makes LEGO Version of Micah

This would be impossible, but it would be interesting to see if there was some mannerism of Jack that did connect to Arthur. Unfortunately, that’s not the case. The Red Dead Redemption video has gone viral because of this possibility—accumulating nearly 140,000 views across 11 days from an otherwise small YouTube account, Melodic Satisfaction Productions—and it has likely gotten several of those fans with its troll.

The short 5-second video, as seen above, just shows Jack Marston coughing. This obviously doesn’t mean much of anything in Red Dead Redemption, but fans also know that Arthur Morgan dies in Red Dead Redemption 2 from tuberculosis. It is a disease that attacks the lung, and there are several gameplay segments/scenes where Morgan coughs and struggles to get his breath. With just 5 seconds, Melodic Satisfaction Productions was able to reel people in and deliver a powerful, darkly hilarious troll.

Red Dead fans seem to be taking it in stride, though. One comment talks about how this video could’ve gone in any number of ways, but instead, chose “one little discreet cough” to bring everyone back “like a punch to the gut.” Others used the moment to joke about the possibility of Arthur Morgan being Jack Marston’s father, which obviously doesn’t correlate but is a funny nod to in-game dialogue and suggestions that John may not be Jack’s father (he probably is, though).

Either way, this video has likely brought as many laughs as it has heartbreaks, and that really speaks to the franchise’s popularity. Video game characters die all the time, but only a few can leave a lasting impact like Arthur Morgan (and John Marston’s death before him).

Red Dead Redemption 2 is available on PC, PS4, Stadia, and Xbox One.

MORE: Red Dead Redemption Fan Finds Big Arthur Morgan Mural in Mexican Restaurant