-(1).jpg?q=50&fit=contain&w=1140&h=&dpr=1.5)
It seems nobody is scared of a gorgeous 9-foot-tall vampire lady; she's too pretty. So it's up to indie horror games to create true nightmares that actually frighten players instead of toying with their mommy issues (though that's not a bad thing either). Thankfully, some indie horror games are unapologetic about their villains.
A lot of them look like they were plucked straight out of someone's delirious fever dream. Some of them are on the same level as Silent Hill's sleep paralysis monstrosities. It's just that they get overshadowed too much by AAA-game horror villains. To give them the spotlight they deserve, here are some of the most imposing, symbolic, and genuinely horrific indie game villains.
8 Spider (Limbo)
Limbo had a simple premise. It's a puzzle-platformer game where players need to guide the soul of a nameless boy who's traversing the edges of hell, or limbo. For most of his time on the Forest level, however, he gets chased by a giant Spider whose origins are unknown and whose goal is simple enough; to kill the boy.
Once players get over the initial shock and fear factor of the spider (particularly arachnophobes), certainly symbolisms come to mind. Theories have emerged that the Spider represents death above all things. Other theories point to the boy's greatest fears back when he was alive. Regardless, an unstoppable and unreasonable enemy is not something one wants to encounter during a self-reflective journey about mortality.
7 Water Lurker (Amnesia: Dark Descent)
Amnesia: Dark Descent was one of the pioneers of a different breed of horror where players didn't have any means of fighting back. Of course, that wouldn't have been as impactful as it was if not for Dark Descent's hair-raising and mostly obscure monsters. Arguably, the worst among them was the Water Lurker, or the creature known as Kaernk.
The genius in Kaernk's design is that he's mostly invisible and only stalks flooded areas in the game. So players will have to play "the floor is lava" and avoid water, lest they be slaughtered by an invisible monster whose presence is only announced through panicked ripples and splashes. It's so trauma-inducing that even if players have already vanquished Kaernk, that old fear and feeling of water still lingers.
6 Monika (Doki Doki Literature Club)
Doki Doki Literature Club is a different breed of horror as it's mostly psychological. However, the way it breaks the fourth wall and even messes with the players' game files is just unsettling and quite novel for a horror game. One of the characters, Monika even became self-aware and found out that she was in a video game.
Even worse, she knew that she had the power to alter the game's variables. This led to her changing other characters' personalities and developing a stalker complex for the player. Monika shows just how creepy and invasive a true yandere character can be as she tries to manipulate and even mess with the player's psyche.
5 Slenderman (Slender: The Eight Pages)
Slenderman from Slender: The Eight Pages became so popular in the previous decade that someone gave him a horror film. Although the movie flopped, Slenderman's cult status as one of the most slowburn and subtle horror monsters remains intact.
The funny thing is, Slenderman started off as a creepypasta or an internet horror meme. It's unexpected for a freakishly tall, lanky, and faceless horror monster made up from the twisted subconscious of the internet community to actually haunt players in his own dedicated digital space. That's why Slender: The Eight Pages is quite significant for the indie scene.
4 The Janitor (Little Nightmares)
While monsters like The Lady in Little Nightmares make for a fine main antagonist, early precedents such as meeting the Janitor for the first time can be more memorable. He's one of the major horrors the players will meet throughout their playthrough, and it's safe to say the Janitor more than sets the tone.
Everything he does, from collecting toys, to wrapping up children is just creepy and presents more risky questions than answers. The sounds he makes whenever chasing the players or telegraphing his approach will also embed some nasty memories into the player's mind.
3 Emilia (Pacify)
Emilia is a classic horror lady ghoul with tattered clothes and a permanent case of bad hair day straight out of Japanese and Thai horror films. She's the star in Pacify, except she's better regarded as a black hole that will unleash the horrors of the abyss on whoever she catches.
Compared to the other frantic indie horror villains here, Emilia is slow and players can even dance around her to avoid her. But that doesn't take away from her weird stride and sinister smile. At times, she can even surprise players with a jump scare. The only way to defeat her is to find a way to pacify her, true enough to the game's name.
2 William Afton (Five Nights At Freddy's)
Speaking of stopping horror game villains, William Afton from Five Nights At Freddy's begs to differ. He's practically immortal and is able to cheat death despite losing his physical form. In fact, for most of the game, players don't get to know William's original and human form. He mostly shows up through his twisted resurrections.
He mostly reincarnates as his murder bots; Springtrap, Glitchtrap, Scraptrap, and Burntrap, thanks to William's knowledge of robotics. Apart from robotics, William Afton is also a serial killer and the one who's directly responsible for most of the murders, disappearances, and other violent incidents in the series.
1 Cannibals & Mutants (The Forest)
The Forest does have an overarching main antagonist, but most of the time, it's his creations that strike fear into the hearts and minds of the hapless players. These creations are the mutants and to some extent, the cannibals all over the game world. The first time players see these cannibals is always a disturbing experience because of their grimy appearance and their mumbles.
And just when players though they're safe from the cannibals of the surface, the mutants will rear their ugly heads once players venture into cave systems. In the dank blackness of those underground networks, even a small flicker of flame won't represent hope—it will only show the grotesque visage of these mutants.