‘Rocksmith’ Review

Published 3 years ago by , Updated December 17th, 2014 at 3:36 pm,

Rocksmith Review Game Rant’s Robert Keyes reviews Rocksmith

A few years ago music video games were a dominant genre, making big bucks for publishers and hardware manufacturers through rapid launches of sequels, licensed spin-offs, digital music stores and a growing arsenal of higher end peripherals.

With Rocksmith, the first authentic guitar game, Ubisoft aims to take the music video game genre to the next level: realism.  Does Rocksmith succeed in bringing the real guitar experience to both beginners and experienced musicians, while still offering fun gameplay? Read our review to find out.

Rocksmith ships with a Real Tone USB cable which lets users plug a real electric guitar into a PS3, Xbox 360 or Windows PC. Players must therefore have an electric guitar – or any guitar with a 6.35mm/1/4″ jack – to play the game or they can purchase the $200 bundle which comes with a Epiphone Les Paul Junior guitar.

Authenticity is the key. Gone are the plastic 5-button toys and in is an actual instrument. Fire up the game, choose which hand to strum the guitar with and begin the Rocksmith journey. No gimmicks. The guitar actually works and picks up on every note and string played, but be warned,  it is not capable of correctly registering all guitar techniques, including a few of the ones taught in the game.

The game comes loaded with approximately 50 songs, a variety of old and new and most very recognizable and hand-picked for their guitar focus. From Nirvana and The Rolling Stones to The Black Keys and Stone Temple Pilots, there should be a few hits for any aspiring guitarist. Additional songs are and will continue to be available through the in-game store as DLC.

Rocksmith is primarily a single-player game and is not a substitute for the party game appeal that Rock Band offers. It does support a two-player mode if you have a second Real Tone USB Cable and guitar or a microphone. The basic gameplay is not unlike other music games with the guitar neck laid out on screen with notes and chords popping up in succession. For guitarists familiar with traditional tablature, there’s an option to invert the standard display.

The game’s campaign is structured into a career of sorts, the Journey as it’s called in game, and the experience is meant to simulate that of an amateur guitarist on the small venue circuit, performing small sets until moving onto another. Songs can be rehearsed and replayed until hitting a certain point score recommended before the player is event-ready, at least according to what the game believes is “event ready.” Between performances, while progressing down the journey/timeline, Rocksmith also makes recommendations to help players improve from their current level of expertise. These includes skill challenges and mini-games.

The mini-games in the Guitarcade are very fun but must be unlocked as the player progresses – each has a specific function in teaching a different technique, from learning the frets and strings with ‘Ducks’ and ‘Super Ducks’ to learning chords with ‘Dawn of the Chordead.’ This is really the only time where Rocksmith feels like a traditional video game since the game does away with things like the colorful character avatars of Guitar Hero - all performances are played from a first-person perspective so the player will never see him or herself or the band on stage. The game’s different venues are superfluous and the odd looking crowd never changes, nor does the gameplay between rehearsing and performing at an “event.”

Rocksmith journey timeline

The Rocksmith Journey

As for the technique challenges, there are many of them, each teaching a very specific guitar lesson. With these, Rocksmith begins to shine as a learning tool but the tutorial videos do not always fully explain for beginners what needs to be done and this is especially troublesome for some of the techniques – like the palm mute – where the game is unable to register the action. To proceed in these events, we needed to do the opposite of what it was instructing us to do.

While performing a song, the game is designed to automatically adjust the amount of notes, combos or chords on screen depending on how the player performs, even in techniques if said chord hasn’t been demonstrated to the player. If the user is experienced, they can play away and the game will increase the difficulty and add more notes, accordingly.

The adaptive A.I. is an interesting feature and works well at recognizing how the player is performing. In theory, this game design choice is genius and it follows the mindset that players don’t know how good they are at a song when picking it up, so the game helps determine that for them as they play along. It does not however, actually help the player learn the song or chords in segments or as a whole and this is the a part of the game’s major issue: restrictions.

The AI feature cannot be altered and there exists no option for players to select and stick with a difficulty level before beginning a song should they choose to do so.  You get what you’re given based on what you do on the fly and this hinders experienced players who want to play a song proper from the beginning and all the way through, while at the same time making it too difficult for beginners trying to learn in stages.

Rocksmith minigames

Rocksmith mini-games

As a learning tool, the game both in song and in the technique challenges, is over-rewarding and because of that, beginners will be praised and given an increased challenge when they are not ready. Even if doing a technique challenge and hitting every note incorrectly, the game will push them through to the challenge after the brief tutorial. Rocksmith is good about getting players playing right off the bat, but there needs to be the option for users to focus on learning as well.

Rocksmith rewards repetition over skill development and doesn’t offer enough in terms of detailed and informative (read: complete) tutorials to help beginners, even though the game is clearly designed with the inexperienced in mind. Players can earn a gold rating on a specific technique by repeatedly finishing it with only mild success, rather than needing to have accomplished it at a higher difficulty.

Rocksmith includes features that help the player tune the guitar and learn the basics of guitar playing, but it does not teach them how to tune a guitar themselves or how to play all of the chords. For experienced players, jumping into the song selector and choosing to play with chords is great fun, and with Rocksmith’s amp feature, different pedals and effects can be added when unlocked and played with freely in Amp Mode.

Rocksmith plays as a very cool, high potential tech demo but as a complete game with lasting appeal or as a comprehensive learning tool, it does not fully succeed. For the most part, Rocksmith works well and it does offer the next evolution in music gaming – it just is lacking in a few basic features, further hampered by slow and restrictive menus that frequently require loading and saving screens while navigating. Due to the nature of Rocksmith being an authentic musical experience, it’s not a pick-up-and-play game. A high willingness to play and a long-term time investment is required to fully take advantage of the game’s features, just like learning any instrument.

The standard $80 package, which includes the USB cable, and the $200 bundle which comes packed with a legit electric guitar are great deals. For players who have put in time with Rock Band and Guitar Hero, especially those who made use of the Pro Guitar, Rocksmith is something that needs to be played, even if to simply prepare for Rocksmith 2 which we hope expands and fleshes out all of the features.

-

Follow me on Twitter @rob_keyes.

Rocksmith is currently available for the PS3 and Xbox 360.

Our Rating:

3 out of 5

TAGS: PS3, Rocksmith, Ubisoft

14 Comments

Post a Comment

  1. I’ve been looking forward to a game like this since the first Guitar Hero came out, and I’m not disappointed one bit.

    However, like stated in the review, some of the techniques do not register correctly, particularly palm muting and harmonics (at least for me). As someone who has been playing guitar for 10 years now, I know when I’m doing something correctly, and its irritating for me to see the game tell me I’m wrong.

    • Is the game any fun? Can you just play around with it like if it were an multi-effects pedal? I play the guitar as well and Im curious about this game. And how “realistic” will it get? Is it just 1 note combos. Do we really play chords? solos? Improv? I like the whole GH concept of SHREDING!!!! Does this get close or is it like the youtube videos where its just like ding ding ding dang dang dang dung dung dung deng deng deng. Lol

      • You can play single note arrangements, chord arrangements, combo arrangements of the songs in the game. Can’t improvise solos although the game won’t penalize you for playing extra notes as long as you hit the ones that are on the note highway.

        It’s pretty realistic in that the game recognizes a ton of articulations like bends, slides, harmonics, palm mutes, etc.

        The Amp mode in the game turns your console and TV into an amp and effects chain and you can put together dozens of in-game amps, cabinets, and pedals to customize a tone and play whatever you want.

        And yes, it’s fun.

      • 619691,

        Yeap, it’s definitely fun to play. If you put in the time, you’ll unlock cool features to use and play with in Amp Mode.

        • Fun to play, yet it only warrants a 3/5? Hmmmm.

  2. After making my way through the first four sets I’ve got to say that I’m really unimpressed with the song selections. A couple of them are sooo bad that I actually made my way through them with the game muted. The fret numbers that appear on the screen are confusing at times making it almost impossible to tell which fret that you are supposed to play.
    Overall I give the game a 7 out of ten only because it’s the first attempt at bringing the actual instrument to a game. I hope that future attempts will be far superior to this one.

  3. I’d welcome a patch or even in the sequel a few things:

    Better sensitivity to certain techniques, such as palm muting and harmonics.

    Less lag between real life plucking of strings and the game sensing it onscreen (yes, I know you can mess with this in-game, but I don’t see the reason for the lag in the first place)

    More songs (of course), perhaps some heavier stuff, as Slither was probably the heaviest song on here, and it was fun as hell.

    A drum track to play to in the amplifier sessions.

    An option to record the amplifier sessions (with drum track and bass guitar, this would be an amazing song recording tool)

    Bass guitar functionality (natch)

  4. Rocksmith, a good game for music fans

  5. cool review…one of my favorite games. love it love it love it!!

  6. On overall I really liked the game, but, as the article said, the design saving and slow loadings all the time really bother me… also, another thing that really bother me on the game are the section training tools, like, you can’t control they, and you have a limited number of attempts, it’s like, if I wanna learn that solo, I wanna stick on it, maybe for hours until I get it right, but on the game, you have a few options, and all of they only allow you 5 tries, after that it quits, and you have to select menus again… if that was fast, it would be ok, but it’s slow, and I can’t see any point on doing that restriction…

    This game did a nice initial work, but a lot should be improved, and what makes me mad is the stuff that can make this game really great are much simpler than complex stuff that they did…

  7. i have never played a guitar before and because i cant afford the HIGH prices of lessons this was the only way i thought i could learn. why do people bash things? i mean seriously if you have been playing for 10+ years, why would you use this? if you think that sitting in a room full of other students trying to learn is the way to go, then how about you pay for my lessons because i cant afford 50.00 a hour. sorry but this isnt the old school america where people are made of money. this is the new school where our government has ruined everything, including the economy

  8. The game hates my Rickenbacker: http://dougberry.hubpages.com/hub/Review-of-Rocksmith-Authentic-Guitar-Games-for-PS3

  9. I have someone that wants this game. We have WII not xbox or PS3. So my question: Has anyone used the PC version? Is it as good as the others? I am NOT a gamer, so I do not want to just buy it. Thank you for your help

  10. I have just bought this game on ps3 and have been playing it for a day, and had one session with mates and have a few comments about it.

    lag: there is no problem. Sure individual people may have problems, but if you set up your video and audio equipment properly, lag is quite minimal. On my samsung tv, I turned off all types of picture processing, and set it for ‘game mode’. I have a digital audio link to my amp, but this introduces quite some audio lag, so I ran an alternate analog cable between the tv and the amp, and the result is quite good. It sounds fine, feels natural and is smooth to play.

    Auto AI: This is a pain. The way I like to play these games when friends are around is to pick individual songs, pick a difficulty level and everyone with some guitar skills should be able to have a go. In my case, playing on my profile which I had started learning the guitar on, several songs have now raised the AI to match my mates much better guitar skills. Some of the drills now begin at a really advanced point, and there is no way to wind them back to amateur for myself.

    It would be much better if you could adjust the difficulty level for any given song or drill manually when you try to play it. On the first night of playing guitar I got the first difficulty increasing drill of the queens of the stone age song down pat. I had a good run and increased difficulty about 5 levels. The next day, it now begins on hard. I want to wind it back and do the whole exersize again to improve my skills, but no it begins too hard for me.

    UI: The whole UI is a pain. The ‘repeater’ type drills should go on forever until you quit. Just as you are getting in the zone for a riff, it exists, and you have let it save your progress and click about 5 menu options and demonstrate your guitar is still tuned, when really you just want to be practicing the same part over and over. Its quite clunky to navigate the menus.

    Overall though, the game engine and playing is done well. Just please guys, give it a much better UI!

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.