Rated M for Mature

Published 4 years ago by , Updated February 9th, 2012 at 9:30 pm,

Rated M for Mature Game Rant

The ESRB’s view of maturity is very simple: blood, guts, violence and sex. But is that really what ‘mature’ is?

If we pick up a dictionary, it tells us that Mature is:

  • Intended for or restricted to adults, esp. by reason of explicit sexual content or the inclusion of violence or obscene language: mature movies.
  • Fully developed in body or mind, as a person: a mature woman.

Society tells us that the term ‘Mature Videogame’ is oxymoronic. There is no such thing, for one automatically cancels out the other. Videogames are designed to transport the player to the days of their youth; a place where anything was possible and joy was to be found around every corner.

The term ‘mature’ implies a life led by adults, one filled with tough decisions, stress and hard work.

Can a videogame be tough, yet playful? Can it elicit joy, whilst simultaneously causing the player emotional turmoil? How on earth can a game be fun and mature?

First, we need to ask:

What constitutes a ‘Mature Videogame’?

If I walk down the aisle in any Best Buy/Walmart/Gamestop, it’s likely that I’ll be walking past dozens of M-rated games. Manhunt 2, Fallout 3, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, Grand Theft Auto IV, Resident Evil 5… Each has been given the same rating – and yet each game’s content is vastly different.

How do the governing officials dictate what is a ‘Mature’ game? How do we, as videogame players, decide what we think is mature? Is it a game that provokes a mature emotional response within the player? Is it one that includes ‘mature topics’ (regardless of the way they’re handled) — i.e. sex, violence, swearing? Or is it a game that may include a childish subject matter, but deals with it in an appropriate, mature way?

Ethan Mars Heavy Rain Game Rant

The “Emotional Response” Argument

Some might say this is a bit of a non-starter — after all, every game is designed to invoke an emotional response from the player. But can joy, elation and happiness be regarded in the same manner as lust, betrayal and fear?

The latter triad of emotions are incredibly complex and usually reserved for adults. Of course, a child may feel fear, but usually their fear is a fear of the unknown or of circumstances that they do not/cannot understand. In my opinion, fear laced with understanding is far more frightening — something only a mature person could experience.

Then there’s the idea of love. Can a videogame elicit the emotion of love? The tag-line of the recently released interactive-experience Heavy Rain asks “How far would you go to save someone you love?” But is it possible for a videogame to invoke that response? If it does, then surely Heavy Rain is one of the first true ‘Mature’ games.

After all, ask the parents of any 16 year-old who claims to be in love and they’ll invariably tell you something along the lines of, “It’s not love. They don’t know what love is.” Is love an emotion/process only reserved for a mature audience?

In my opinion Heavy Rain re-established what it means to be a videogame. By creating believable characters in a fictional world — a world grounded in reality — the emotional impact of each decision made by the player was greatly intensified, leaving me agonizing over each and every decision I made.

Heavy Rain Bad Choices Game Rant

In creating characters with human flaws, Quantic Dream have realized a cast that the player can identify with and relate to.

Speaking to GamePro, Quantic Dream’s lead designer, David Cage, had this to say:

“We are all shades of grey. All of us have skills, but we all have secrets. Things that are hidden that make us suffer. It’s that complexity, and those shades of grey that make us more interesting, and in the case of these characters it meant that I could move things away from the standard archetypes.”

Does this make Heavy Rain a mature videogame? Does the fact that the game handles ‘true’ adult themes such as love, relationships, life and death, in a convincing and adult manner solidify its status as a mature experience?

Perhaps the most interesting design choice in Heavy Rain is the complete absence of a ‘Game Over’ screen — much like life, it forces you to accept your mistakes and move on, regardless of the consequences. The knowledge that your mistakes will impact the way the game plays out (including the death of some major characters) makes the experience far more tense, forcing the player to quickly weigh the available options in a short amount of time — and act in the way they think best.

Having completed Heavy Rain, I felt a sense of pure agony at the game’s finale. The knowledge that my actions and my decisions led to the game’s eventual tragedy physically hurt. It may just be a videogame with tens of thousands of pixels on the screen, but to me, that didn’t matter. I caused the death of someone I felt attached to, and in turn, I paid the emotional price.

Is this true videogame maturity?

Continue to Page 2 of Rated M for Mature!

« 1 2 3View All»

TAGS: Broken Sword, Fallout 3, Flight of the Amazon Queen, Grand Theft Auto 4, Heavy Rain, iPhone, Manhunt 2, Modern Warfare 2, Nintendo, PC, PS3, Quantic Dream, Resident Evil 5, Rockstar Games, Super Mario Galaxy, The Legend of Zelda, Wii

14 Comments

Post a Comment

  1. Article contradicts itself. You can't say Heavy Rain is mature in one breath for allowing choice then slam GTA as “immature” because its choices are tied in with “immature” actions. The very fact that GTA allows an open world environment in which the gamer is empowered to imprint their own morals should be an indication of how mature it is. Just because the gamer themselves chooses to be immature shouldn't steal from the games standing. You even accept this notion later in the article,

    “Or the idea that one person really can make a difference in a giant world. I’d argue that these were mature themes, wouldn’t you?”

    Which is why I don't understand how you can state GTA isn't mature. Anyone who played the ending will know the had to make a pretty deep choice of love or blood – the consequences of which had ramifications on how the game thereafter was perceived. There's no reason this choice is any less profound than anything found in Heavy Rain, I'd even argue that GTA's is more important because the game allows you to live on after the decision and continue to experience the world through the decision made whereas in Heavy Rain – the game ends eventually. Your decision, while important at the time, will inevitably mean nothing because the game world is destined to end when you hit the final credits.

    Which is why I don't understand what the articles trying to say about mature gaming. You say a game is mature if it treats audience like adults, so how is free-will and the ability to mould ones experience to their own desire not a mature aspect?

  2. That's merely my perception of what is a mature game, Shaun. I tried to look at every argument, and every game therein, from a different point of view. GTA's overall theme is incredibly mature – I believe the American Dream to be an incredibly interesting and profound notion – but there are other aspects to the game that may bring that concept down.

  3. A wandering, non-sensical, empty article with a very limp ending. Your article needs bite. You're waffling like an old lady building up to posing a question which instead of answering you pop in a ? at the end.

    Nice effort for a 17 year old, but not a mature writer as yet.

  4. Well thanks for the critique, but I never planned on answering the question. As I think I showed, there's far too many different ideas as to what constitutes 'maturity' and so to choose a single definition would be asinine. I chose my preference, but that would be different for everyone that read it.

  5. I would argue that Heavy Rain isn't mature because, judging by one of the definitions used in the article, almost nothing in the story is convincing. It's so polarizing because Heavy Rain is like the laziest, most ambitious game I've ever played. The voice-acting is atrocious, the character models are just okay and don't even get me started on the story. It's filled with nonsensical plot twists and deceptive red herrings. It's not even clever writing, it's just like the writers are lying to you.

  6. “Having completed Heavy Rain, I felt a sense of pure agony at the game’s finale. The knowledge that my actions and my decisions led to the game’s eventual tragedy physically hurt” ~WOW — I need to play this

  7. To me the answer is simple. If the game has anything added that a young person wont understand or shouldn't understand is mature. And those parents that just buy a game without looking at the ESRB rating or did and just don't care are idiots.

  8. Yeah, it was pretty intense man. I loved it, as I think is evident!

  9. So what if it's something like Rapelay? Rape is something that a young child shouldn't understand, but I wouldn't say that the way it's handled in said game is mature.

  10. When is rape ever immature? no matter what way it's handled.

  11. When it's glorified and turned into a harmless 'game'.

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

Be Social, Follow Us!!